Each episode of Creeped out features a different protagonist per episode. Every protagonist is a child, preteen, or teenager.

Listed here are the protagonists and the episodes they appear in:

Slapstick: Jessie

Cat Food: Stu

Trolled: Sam

Marti: Kim

A Boy Called Red: Vincent

The Call: Pearl

Bravery Badge: Dent

Spaceman: Spud and Thomas

Kindlesticks: Esme

Shed No Fear: Greg and Dave

The Traveller: Brandon and Jodie

Side Show(Parts One and Two): Ace